IMO there is really only question that you need to see answered. Are the vast majority of type A's getting signed to 2 or more year deals? If yes, (which I'm almost 100% certain they are) then telling a releasing team they now have to risk an extra year is literally going to mean nothing to them. If the evidence shows that they are getting signed to a 2 year deal already then logically thinking I don't see how it changes anyone's decision making. If I'm the releasing team I'm effectively not risking anything more and if I'm the signing team I was already going to sign him to 2 years anyway so who cares if that's now mandatory.
I don't like seeing borderline guys get comp A either, but making the years go from 1 to 2 simply logically doesn't change the situation.
I don't like seeing borderline guys get comp A either, but making the years go from 1 to 2 simply logically doesn't change the situation.