All-Time FCM Team

[mattynokes]

After next season (2034) and our 25th FCM campaign I will be reviewing our all-time team. I will be selecting a lineup w/ DH, bench, and 10 pitchers. There will be one spot left open for you to vote on.

If you think I missed a name, let me know. But note that longevity and number of quality years is highly being taken into consideration. Simply cause a player was elite for a couple of seasons doesn't mean he should be considered. I believe every retired player I have so far has at least 1,500 hits or 150 Wins/3.00 ERA or 300 Saves. Awards are also highly taken into consideration. Lastly, active players will be considered by their current stats, not what their potential future production will be.

Players must be computer generated and must be in line to have 12 seasons (below age on the top of the player profile) played after the 2034 season.

Catchers
Josh Jarmel
Gabriel Gamora

First Base
Steve Miller
Alan Bent
Manny Capestany
Tim Vandyke
Jose Rabena

Second Base
Matt McArthur

Third Base
Ed Edwards
Jamie Valdez
Aaron Wittmann

Short Stop
Jay Sullivan (2B)
Peter Potter

Left Field
Manuel Vargas
James Aitkenhead (RF)
Frank Prywes (RF)

Center Field
Rafael Romero

Right Field
Joaquin Murillo (CF)
Mike Gartner
Dominic Fulgham (1B)

Starters
Boris Turner
Max Roberts
Jeff Wych
Alfonso Predrasa
Edgar Vaio
Steve Eickholt
Fletcher Conyers
Adrian Curray
Brian Colley
Jacob Widdup
Corey Bosworth
Stan Lomax
Joe Arnold
Ryan Christner (RP)
Donovan Pace

Relievers
Rob Wood
Clay Rosen
Brian Metcalf
Alan Jackson
Edmund Poez
James Threadgold

Please don't turn this into a pissing match of who is better than who.

[AndyP]

Skipworth at catcher, Ramos at third, Enrique Rodriguez at second, OF Gartner

[mattynokes]

Skipworth at catcher, Ramos at third, Enrique Rodriguez at second, OF Gartner

Unfortunately only Gartner is eligible since the players must be computer generated. Skipworth is a real player while Ramos and Rodriguez were IFAs.

[dlee2499]

OF Gary Drye?

[Peter]

how about splitting these AL and NL, and for guys that spent time in both you could use where they spent their prime

[mattynokes]

OF Gary Drye?

He won't have played 12 seasons in the bigs after next season. As far as I'm willing to predict/project is next season. The reason I have this qualification is if you compare his numbers to the others I have listed, he falls way short. In time it's possible he reaches the top hitters, but if his career ended after next year he wouldn't cut it.

how about splitting these AL and NL, and for guys that spent time in both you could use where they spent their prime

That would be even more work. I think a top 25 of sorts will be just fine.

[mattynokes]

I'll open it up to any player that is at least in his tenth year. These players will still not make the list (they need 12 years), but they will be considered as up and comers to potentially some day make the list.