+- First Class Mogul (https://www.firstclassmogul.com)
+-- Forum: General Manager's Office (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Forum: Trade Central (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+---- Forum: Trades Vetoed (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=36)
+---- Thread: NYY/ATL (/showthread.php?tid=11232)
Pages:
1
2
NYY/ATL - bh1225 - 02-12-2012
getC/1B Josh Jarmel 95 32yo 15.7M thru 29
getSS/DH Starlin Castro 73 36yo 20M thru 2027
This years yanks 1st rounder
Yanks accept. The draft class is overhyped imo. And I want to win right now, plus dumping castro and landing jarmel actually saves us $.
RE: NYY/ATL - piazza31 - 02-12-2012
simplest explination i can give
MY team sucks this year and will hopefully get a high dp next year
jarnel eats away at my cap castro does it for 2 years
jarnel gets me a pick in an amazing draft
I signed jarnel cuz i wanted to compete my team didnt help me so yah
RE: NYY/ATL - AndyP - 02-12-2012
Approved
RE: NYY/ATL - mattynokes - 02-12-2012
Veto
This is a clear sign and trade. Jarmel (and McArthur for that matter) were signed to four year deals in the off-season. This wasn't a low key signing where things just didn't go according to plan. Two months just isn't long enough for players of this caliber.
RE: NYY/ATL - piazza31 - 02-12-2012
quote the DJ, "if given a good reason there can be exceptions" this is not a sign and trade why the fuck would i want to sign a guy to help me compete than faulter
RE: NYY/ATL - mattynokes - 02-12-2012
(02-12-2012, 08:37 PM)piazza31 Wrote: quote the DJ, "if given a good reason there can be exceptions" this is not a sign and trade why the fuck would i want to sign a guy to help me compete than faulter
You only gave it two months to play out. Have some patience, rather than always expecting instant gratification. You have a good team that's just under performing. Maybe 2026 wouldn't have been your year, but Mc and Jarmel would still be under contract for three more years to right the ship.
RE: NYY/ATL - piazza31 - 02-12-2012
maybe that might be true, but with attaway out of the picture, no cf, no c, and no bulpen its not likely at all i'd compete in a division with fla,nats,and mets + with houston and cincy its nearly impossible to make the playoffs
RE: NYY/ATL - Mad_Trapper - 02-12-2012
i have to veto too
If this was the same situation and at the trade deadline I might let it go, but we are only at the draft and if I was one of the teams who was trying to sign him in the offseason I would be upset.
RE: NYY/ATL - bh1225 - 02-12-2012
I don't get the problem honestly. He earned the rights to this player during FA with the intentions of competing. He obviously is not doing too well. Maybe it is early to quit on him, but I think it is a reasonable move. Especially for all we know the next couple drafts might not be this strong, and trading him in the future might be more difficult.
RE: NYY/ATL - mattynokes - 02-12-2012
Put yourself in the shoes of Mav (LAD) who lost out on him by $250K per year.