06-26-2012, 02:21 AM
(06-25-2012, 11:57 PM)psbaseballfan27 Wrote: I like JHC for simplistic reasons. I dont wanna have to figure out which picks I will lose by signing players. I'd rather know whats gonna happen right away when signing a player.
How wouldn't you know right away? There would be only one compensation round. If you sign one compensation player you lose a 5th, two signed and you additional lose your 6th, and if a third player is signed you'd lose your 4th.
The differences are...
Current:
Use JHC's formula, Fallback
Type A/B
Two compensation rounds
Lose picks based on comp type (4th if three signed)
Proposed #1:
Any player can be compensated, as long as a qualifying offer is met (some sort of Top # (10?) average salary at position)
No Type A/B
One compensation round
Lose 5th if one signed, 5th and 6th if two signed (4th if three signed)
Proposed #2:
Use JHC's formula, Fallback
No Type A/B
One compensation round
Lose 5th if one signed, 5th and 6th if two signed (4th if three signed)
Cleveland Record: 7313-6184 (.542) [2054-2071, 2083-2104, 2110-2153]
AL Post: 24 (ALC), 18 (WC) - ALDS Win: 17 - ALCS Champ: 9 - WS Champ: 5