Poll: Should there be Instant Replay?

'PR' · (This post was last modified: 08-16-2010, 12:45 PM by 'PR'.)

Ok so we've heard all about it. I want to see what this league's point of view is on the dreaded concept of INSTANT REPLAY.

Scott · 08-16-2010, 03:04 PM

I voted only homerun calls. Let's face it, that is the only game changing play - A homerun.

Umpires have been a part of the game for almost 150 years, why change it now?

***jps93*** · 08-16-2010, 04:21 PM

I voted the two challenges. That way, the game isn't slowed down too much and the coach uses his discretion to challenge whatever he wants.

'PR' · (This post was last modified: 08-16-2010, 04:43 PM by 'PR'.)

I voted NEVER.....I believe the human element is what makes baseball so unique compared to other sports. This is the only game other than soccer (And who in the US watches that?) where a human calls the final shots. Can't say the same about basketball, football or hockey.

Btw Scotty, the home run isn't the only game changing play. What about a game ending 9-2 double play with 1 out and the bases loaded in the bottom of the ninth where the home team was down by one run. The sac fly would've scored the tying run. Is that not game changing?

Poll: Should there be Instant Replay? You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
At all times when a call is questionable	16.67%	1	16.67%
A team is given 2 challenges per game to use on a questionable call	50.00%	3	50.00%
Only on questionable home run calls	0%	0	0%
Only on questionable fair/foul balls down the line	16.67%	1	16.67%
Only on questionable home run calls and fair/foul balls down the line	0%	0	0%
The use of K-Zone to conduct officiating on a pitch	0%	0	0%
NEVER	16.67%	1	16.67%
Total		6 vote(s)	100%