mike
Offline
Florida Marlins GM - Holds record for most times to quit and come back
Posts: 3,931
Threads: 1,225
Joined: Jul 2010
To help not drive Andy nuts I suggest for every UDFA you pay 1mil fee, basically equalling the total of a late 6th. Just a small deterrent for teams to not go crazy signing guys just to release them a half year later.
sxr007
Offline
Posts: 3,004
Threads: 771
Joined: Jan 2012
I like that idea. Whoever came up with that is a genius.
Dodgers 2036 - Present
Padres 2026-2035
23 NL West Championships
9 Wild Cards
National League Champion 2057, 2060, 2095, 2115
WORLD SERIES CHAMPION 2057
mzylinski
Offline
Seattle Mariners GM/President of Operations
Posts: 4,056
Threads: 1,218
Joined: Jul 2010
Hate it should not have to pay to take a gamble on some UDFA allows more cash fluid teams to make more gambles making it unfair for more cash conscience folks
 GM
'08- Current: Pirates GM Record
'56-'08: Seattle GM Record 4606-3510 .568 win%
'20-'32: San Francisco GM Record 875-1231 .415 win%
'10-'14: Minnesota GM Record 324-324 .500 win%
World Series Champion 2010, 2089, 2092, 2095
American League Champion 2010, 2062, 2089, 2092, 2093, 2095
Best Record Full Year (Regular Season and Playoffs Combined): 131-45 .744 win%
Winner of first ever FCM World Series
cadmus2166
Offline
Posts: 2,492
Threads: 793
Joined: Jan 2013
I agree, this is a good idea.
COL GM: 2043 - present
2063 World Champions
2061 NL Champions
mzylinski
Offline
Seattle Mariners GM/President of Operations
Posts: 4,056
Threads: 1,218
Joined: Jul 2010
You do understand this make more work for Andy right? By then having to take money each account. Or we will wait and sign then after he first sim after the draft
GM
'08- Current: Pirates GM Record
'56-'08: Seattle GM Record 4606-3510 .568 win%
'20-'32: San Francisco GM Record 875-1231 .415 win%
'10-'14: Minnesota GM Record 324-324 .500 win%
World Series Champion 2010, 2089, 2092, 2095
American League Champion 2010, 2062, 2089, 2092, 2093, 2095
Best Record Full Year (Regular Season and Playoffs Combined): 131-45 .744 win%
Winner of first ever FCM World Series
mike
Offline
Florida Marlins GM - Holds record for most times to quit and come back
Posts: 3,931
Threads: 1,225
Joined: Jul 2010
no matter when they sign it would still be a udfa so that wouldnt change
mzylinski
Offline
Seattle Mariners GM/President of Operations
Posts: 4,056
Threads: 1,218
Joined: Jul 2010
Again I think this is extremely unnecessary
GM
'08- Current: Pirates GM Record
'56-'08: Seattle GM Record 4606-3510 .568 win%
'20-'32: San Francisco GM Record 875-1231 .415 win%
'10-'14: Minnesota GM Record 324-324 .500 win%
World Series Champion 2010, 2089, 2092, 2095
American League Champion 2010, 2062, 2089, 2092, 2093, 2095
Best Record Full Year (Regular Season and Playoffs Combined): 131-45 .744 win%
Winner of first ever FCM World Series
sxr007
Offline
Posts: 3,004
Threads: 771
Joined: Jan 2012
I think this one is up to Andy. He is the one doing the work.
Dodgers 2036 - Present
Padres 2026-2035
23 NL West Championships
9 Wild Cards
National League Champion 2057, 2060, 2095, 2115
WORLD SERIES CHAMPION 2057
mattynokes
Offline
Cleveland Guardians GM
Posts: 8,984
Threads: 4,310
Joined: Feb 2011
I'm not opposed to a fee, but I think a hard and fast "1M Fee" isn't right. There's varying degrees of talent. One UDFA might be worth the 1M fee, but others won't. Then you have weak drafts where late 6th rounders are getting less than 1M. In the end, it's still giving up more than what it cost you to get your own 6th round pick (which is nothing).
Plus is it just a Sim 4 UDFA signing that creates a 1M fee? What about a June 16 or July 1 signing? Or maybe a guy that doesn't sign until September? Off-Season MiLB / Draft Day signings?
An old league ran blind auction on UDFAs (supplemental picks as they called them). I think that would be the most fair process, but unless Andy can easily create a Google Docs things, like with HOF Voting, I think it'll create too much work.
If I were in Andy's shoes, I would just take notes on who signs UDFAs and releases them quickly and bar them from future UDFA signings. I know I would already have some in mind...
Cleveland Record: 5631-4946 (.532) [2054-2071, 2083-2104, 2110-2135]
AL Post: 16 (ALC), 11 (WC) - ALDS Win: 12 - ALCS Champ: 7 - WS Champ: 4
ALW: Mariners + Angels Record: 1072-864 (.554) [2042-2048, 2105-2110]
AL Post: 3 (ALW), 4 (WC) - ALDS Win: 3 - ALCS Champ: 1 - WS Champ: 1
NLW: Rockies + Padres Record: 3230-2753 (.540) [2017-2042, 2072-2082]
NL Post: 18 (NLW), 4 (WC) - NLDS Win: 7 - NLCS Champ: 4 - WS Champ: 0
AndyP
Offline
Commissioner/7 time Champion
Posts: 15,179
Threads: 3,849
Joined: Jul 2010
My problem with UDFA is the people who sign 12 of them and release all of them by the offseason.
It is so damn obnoxious to go in and edit every guy to a draft day deal. I wouldn't even consider this if people here used even a tiny bit of restraint.
World Champion 2018, 2021, 2026, 2030, 2035, 2037, 2039
AL Champion 12 times
FCM Best Record-Holder - 121-41 2028
Overall Record: 3530-1978 .641%
|
