03-15-2017, 04:11 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-17-2017, 04:59 PM by mattynokes.)
I think the league could highly benefit from adding a defensive WB. After seeing the defensive edits take place for 2 seasons, I've seen something that I find interesting/left out.
As it stands, if the player's field view ratings are high enough, they'll get bumped up to actually being able to play the position. But what about a player like Efrain Montagu in LF? Based off of Andy's guidelines, LF was not touched and Montagu could still run the risk of being a terrible .819 fielder there. There are many others that have the extra predicted positions according to their amateur stats, but can't truly play the position.
Rather than changing the defensive edit guidelines or going back to fix them, I think adding it as a WB program would be a good idea. Anyone like Montagu's case could get a position they played as an amateur fixed. Also, if adding a position (outside of the edit guidelines) makes sense, then that could be done as well. Some ideas...
- A corner outfielder adding 1B to add versatility.
- Any aging player adding 1B simply because that's a natural progression of moving positions.
- A poor defensive infielder moving to the outfield
Maybe we can even come up with a complete list, so that there is no subjectivity. Specifically on the IF moving to the OF, the player would have to be poor defensively and could not take someone like Eric Lindsay (CIN - Sim #5 2070) and move him to CF as the point of this is to give a player a reasonable position to play and Lindsay already has that.
This would be taking a 3B Jonah Lowell (ARI - Sim #5 2070) type and moving him to LF. Or 2B Sean Volpe (MIL- Sim #5 2070) and moving him to LF or CF. They shouldn't lose much or any range or fielding since they're already solidly below average for their current position as well as the positions they're moving to, but IF to OF should see a drop in arm (-5 sounds fair).
I also think having the option to remove positions would be good idea. If Mogul thinks a player can play a certain position, it may have them there even though we know they're terrible. It's like forcing Jim Thome to play 3B at age 40. Mogul would do that if he still had predicted stats at 3B.
For someone like 3B Damian Saragoza (CLE - Sim #5 2070), having Mogul think he can catch is a negative. He'd be much more useful as just a 1B/3B/LF. This one is pretty simple.
Defensive Winterball
Adding
1. Teams can add 2 positions for players each offseason.
2. New position must be approved by Andy.
3. Any age or overall can be done (majors or minors)
4. There is no maximum per player, just 2 total.
5. Cost is $3M per position.
Removing
1. Teams can remove 3 positions for players each offseason.
2. Any age or overall can be done (majors or minors)
3. There is no maximum per player, just 3 total.
4. Cost is $2M per position.
With this I could remove C for Damian Saragoza and add RF in the same offseason for $5M total. I would then have 1 more addition and 2 more removes if I wanted.
Position Adding List
1. Player has played the position as an amateur.
2. Player has secondary position that matches the defensive editing. (i.e. 1B that can also play LF would be approved for RF)
3. 2B can move to any OF if sub-80 range. (He will have -5 arm and roughly the same range and fielding)
4. 3B can move to LF or RF if sub-80 arm or sub-75 range. (He will have -5 arm and roughly the same range and fielding)
5. SS can move to any OF if sub-70 arm or sub-85 range. (He will have -5 arm and roughly the same range and fielding)
6. Any player can add 1B.
As it stands, if the player's field view ratings are high enough, they'll get bumped up to actually being able to play the position. But what about a player like Efrain Montagu in LF? Based off of Andy's guidelines, LF was not touched and Montagu could still run the risk of being a terrible .819 fielder there. There are many others that have the extra predicted positions according to their amateur stats, but can't truly play the position.
Rather than changing the defensive edit guidelines or going back to fix them, I think adding it as a WB program would be a good idea. Anyone like Montagu's case could get a position they played as an amateur fixed. Also, if adding a position (outside of the edit guidelines) makes sense, then that could be done as well. Some ideas...
- A corner outfielder adding 1B to add versatility.
- Any aging player adding 1B simply because that's a natural progression of moving positions.
- A poor defensive infielder moving to the outfield
Maybe we can even come up with a complete list, so that there is no subjectivity. Specifically on the IF moving to the OF, the player would have to be poor defensively and could not take someone like Eric Lindsay (CIN - Sim #5 2070) and move him to CF as the point of this is to give a player a reasonable position to play and Lindsay already has that.
This would be taking a 3B Jonah Lowell (ARI - Sim #5 2070) type and moving him to LF. Or 2B Sean Volpe (MIL- Sim #5 2070) and moving him to LF or CF. They shouldn't lose much or any range or fielding since they're already solidly below average for their current position as well as the positions they're moving to, but IF to OF should see a drop in arm (-5 sounds fair).
I also think having the option to remove positions would be good idea. If Mogul thinks a player can play a certain position, it may have them there even though we know they're terrible. It's like forcing Jim Thome to play 3B at age 40. Mogul would do that if he still had predicted stats at 3B.
For someone like 3B Damian Saragoza (CLE - Sim #5 2070), having Mogul think he can catch is a negative. He'd be much more useful as just a 1B/3B/LF. This one is pretty simple.
Defensive Winterball
Adding
1. Teams can add 2 positions for players each offseason.
2. New position must be approved by Andy.
3. Any age or overall can be done (majors or minors)
4. There is no maximum per player, just 2 total.
5. Cost is $3M per position.
Removing
1. Teams can remove 3 positions for players each offseason.
2. Any age or overall can be done (majors or minors)
3. There is no maximum per player, just 3 total.
4. Cost is $2M per position.
With this I could remove C for Damian Saragoza and add RF in the same offseason for $5M total. I would then have 1 more addition and 2 more removes if I wanted.
Position Adding List
1. Player has played the position as an amateur.
2. Player has secondary position that matches the defensive editing. (i.e. 1B that can also play LF would be approved for RF)
3. 2B can move to any OF if sub-80 range. (He will have -5 arm and roughly the same range and fielding)
4. 3B can move to LF or RF if sub-80 arm or sub-75 range. (He will have -5 arm and roughly the same range and fielding)
5. SS can move to any OF if sub-70 arm or sub-85 range. (He will have -5 arm and roughly the same range and fielding)
6. Any player can add 1B.
Cleveland Record: 5631-4946 (.532) [2054-2071, 2083-2104, 2110-2135]
AL Post: 16 (ALC), 11 (WC) - ALDS Win: 12 - ALCS Champ: 7 - WS Champ: 4
ALW: Mariners + Angels Record: 1072-864 (.554) [2042-2048, 2105-2110]
AL Post: 3 (ALW), 4 (WC) - ALDS Win: 3 - ALCS Champ: 1 - WS Champ: 1
NLW: Rockies + Padres Record: 3230-2753 (.540) [2017-2042, 2072-2082]
NL Post: 18 (NLW), 4 (WC) - NLDS Win: 7 - NLCS Champ: 4 - WS Champ: 0
GM 2050 - 2070, 2122 - present