2151 Draft: This Guy Sucks! - Printable Version +- First Class Mogul (https://www.firstclassmogul.com) +-- Forum: General (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=1) +--- Forum: Draft Analysis (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=117) +---- Forum: Nokes Draft Reviews (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=113) +---- Thread: 2151 Draft: This Guy Sucks! (/showthread.php?tid=72163)

2151 Draft: This Guy Sucks! - mattynokes - 05-18-2026 1. SP Victor Santtago 68/93 I looks like he has a stellar opening build, but being that advanced and giving up a .277 OBA in three of his four years is a downer. 2. SS Edward Williams 65/93 Besides this build being very polarizing development wise, his horrid health has him playing around 125 games per season even if his does develop. 3. SS Chris Wanner 66/89 I get it. Vroom = Steals. However, no amount of speed will make up for him being terrible defensively. So, he’ll have Roberto Alomar’s Range to go with Alfonso Soriano’s Glove and Chuck Knoblach’s Arm. 4. SP Royce Fortin 66/93 Dude LOVES to give up home runs. Good thing he was taken by a team with a 115 HR Effect. 5. SP Seth McIntyre 66/93 Does he want to be a power pitcher? Does he want to be a control pitcher? Who knows. He sure doesn’t. Mixing a control build in with a low GB% is no Bueno. 6. SP Reginald Herod 52/92 I know young with a lot of room to grow, but that room from his Control to his Movement coupled with a few pretty high OBA seasons and it’s a no from me dawg. 7. LF Gil Bastilla 72/94 Swings with his eyes closed. Connects sometimes for moonshots. Also fields with his eyes closed. Should try opening them. 8. 1B Jeff Shuck 65/91 Has what you look for in a 1B. Lefty hitter with power above his overall and a good eye. However, Hokey drafted him. 9. SP Joseph Minnix 63/90 That build is gross. Giving up double digit HRs in three different seasons is gross. A 25% GB rate is also gross. 10. RF Yancy Chandler 67/88 Too good of an eye. Won’t swing at pitches. Yep. 11. 1B Ray Tritle 61/94 Look above. Another dude who doesn’t like to swing the bat. Plus, he doesn’t bring a glove with him to the field. 12. 2B Japanese Guy 75/88 He’s Asian. 13. RF Rapahel Arolio 70/81 This is one of those picks where the GM(s) thinks he’s a genius. Yep. It’s smart to take a guy who’ll peak out in two years and become the best bench player in the league in the middle of the first round. 14. SP Gary McKechnie 65/94 Considering his overall, that build is hot ass in a porta potty in the middle of August. 15. RP Adam Rogers 52/89 A reliever this early? And his best skill is his 92 Health? Hmm. 16. SP Tom Millican 69/90 What a very okay, already jumped, pitcher to have. So inspiring that I don’t even have anything sarcastic to say. 17. SP Wilfredo Cabello 67/93 Why is it that teams who have launching pad parks are the ones drawn to the types of pitchers that they should eschew? 18. SP Dave White 52/86 Too scared to take lefties, so the Reds take a guy who shouldn’t have gone until about a half round later. 19. SP Phil Park 80/93 The good news is that he’ll be MLB ready very soon. The bad news is that his floor and ceiling are the same – Long Relief. 20. 3B Jeremy Prinne 67/88 Can’t hit, can’t run, can’t get on base. But at least he can throw the ball!