+- First Class Mogul (https://www.firstclassmogul.com)
+-- Forum: General Manager's Office (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Forum: Trade Central (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+---- Forum: Trades Vetoed (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=36)
+---- Thread: SFG/CLE (/showthread.php?tid=1955)
SFG/CLE - Scott - 10-06-2010
:SFG: sends:
Todd Lung 2B 77/90 min.
Taylor Tapp RP 74/85 min.
Mark Record RP 78/86 min.
5M
:CLE: sends:
Joe Smith RP 84 4M 2014
Jason Donald 2B 93 4.3M 2014
Toby Anderson SS 88 min. 2014
I really didn't want to do it but here's what I figure. If I want to win, now is my time. I'm sure I'll have a ton of type A/B's this off-season so if I do decide to rebuild then I can collect my picks and have a monster 2015 draft. If I have the budget to re-sign them all then I will. I really think Record and Tapp are monsters but my time is now.
Accept
RE: SFG/CLE - Scott - 10-06-2010
Oh and it's kinda nice having 4 closers
RE: SFG/CLE - chrisveley - 10-06-2010
Agreed, this is a money move and will keep me out of the red at seasons end.
RE: SFG/CLE - dejota - 10-06-2010
I veto this one, I think CLE should net long term financial relief to take a less than ideal return on his closer and two strong middle infielders.
RE: SFG/CLE - Jordan - 10-06-2010
VETO!
CL and MIF are some of the most valued positions in FCM, more is needed to acquire them. This is a gigantic steal On average all three stars have their OVs greater then all the prospects peaks.
RE: SFG/CLE - AndyP - 10-06-2010
Veto. Jason Donald needs to be removed. The deal is fair and approvable for the other two, but Donald should net this value himself damn near.
Cleveland's reasoning, if money, should have been to attach one of these players to a big money guy and make that deal. None of these guys are breaking Cleveland's bank.
I really didn't want to do it but here's what I figure.
yeah right....come on guys, lets try to at least pretend to be objective here. Good god.
RE: SFG/CLE - Jordan - 10-06-2010
Lung is 25 years old -
Only record looks like a good prospect
but all these specs should peak in a season or two, so they have a good chance not to reach their peaks.
The infielders cleveland is sending to San Fran have good vitals across the board, their production might not have necessarily showed it in the past, but these are very good infielders.
RE: SFG/CLE - chrisveley - 10-06-2010
fine, back to trade talks.
RE: SFG/CLE - Scott - 10-06-2010
Lol Andy... but okay..