+- First Class Mogul (https://www.firstclassmogul.com)
+-- Forum: General Manager's Office (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Forum: Trade Central (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+---- Forum: Trades Vetoed (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=36)
+---- Thread: ATL / PHI (/showthread.php?tid=12771)
ATL / PHI - dlee2499 - 04-24-2012
receive:CF Heath Staite 75/88
2B Marty Robertson 86
1B Royce Mitchell 66/84
$1.5M
receive:2B Enrique Rodriguez 92
Pick #25
Pick #35
Accept. I don't see these specs helping my team, and Roberston never turned into the 2B that I wanted. Maybe E-Rod can give that to me, and if not, Taylor will get the chance. And, I'll take the picks.
RE: ATL / PHI - piazza31 - 04-24-2012
accept gain 3 young players, cash and dump salary
RE: ATL / PHI - mattynokes - 04-24-2012
So, PHI gets the three best pieces in this trade? Until Piazza can show his team actually has direction...
Veto
RE: ATL / PHI - piazza31 - 04-24-2012
lets see want specs at positions i like vs not in the draft hmm still rebuilding next question
RE: ATL / PHI - Atlbravesfan27 - 04-24-2012
i'm on the fence on this one, but honestly, you can get better players in the draft than this.. i hate to knit pick every trade, but in my opinion, this makes no damn sense.. veto
RE: ATL / PHI - dlee2499 - 04-24-2012
to mods - please seriously consider this. the deal honestly makes sense from both sides. some of the deals i made in the past i didn't think that, but this one i can see. ATL needs to shed salary, and get some specs. they like what they see in mitchell and staite. they would not fit with my current roster so i will pick up similar specs in the draft. robertson is a solid 2b, don't consider him as a throw away. this is in no way shape or form hurting either team, and i hope you can see that. thanks
RE: ATL / PHI - AndyP - 04-25-2012
I don't think I can approve another Atlanta trade until a clear and detailed plan is laid out. Every deal is friggin schizo. Or as DJ put it - "make up your friggin mind".
So what is the plan? I feel like if we pulled up past trade threads we'd have had 57 different ones in the last few years.
RE: ATL / PHI - jps93 - 04-25-2012
not sure i understand this one either
veto
RE: ATL / PHI - hokeyrules - 04-25-2012
3 veto votes, this has been vetoed.