(07-12-2014, 03:32 PM)rockybull Wrote:

(07-11-2014, 02:50 PM)hokeyrules Wrote: I gave him the b- because he took a 1B when he had Kodo, when they could have used another pitcher or something who I think is better than the 1B. After all I said he was the best or second best 1B........... I just said selecting a 1B at 2nd pick is not what I would have done.

i just think you should be giving out grades based on how good the player is at the spot they took the player. for the most part the gm's here knows their needs and plans better than other gm's.

last sim brino - 1b of the orioles was a 88/94 and already jumped, and he was looking like a stud, now this sim he got an injury and is now a 80/90, so he's going to drop some peak on his b-day. sure, he still has time to get good, but i don't think he'll be as good as what he looked just 1 sim ago. thing is you never know what the next sim holds, you'd be pretty foolish to have just 1 guy at each position and be confident that they will all develop good/great and never drop or get any injuries. you need back up plans. and if all goes well, and your other guys do develop, you can use a guy for trade bait.

i just think you should keep that in mind. i hope that kodo can stay healthy and be great, but a lot can change before he peaks, and it's possible he could have a quick peak end, so i don't know, but it's good to have options. i took who i thought was best player available. there are just never guarantees in mogul when developing specs. i'd be very happy if both kodo and mcgee develop into good starting players, but i also realize that is no guarantee, no matter how good they look today.

(07-12-2014, 09:07 PM)hokeyrules Wrote:

(07-12-2014, 03:32 PM)rockybull Wrote:

(07-11-2014, 02:50 PM)hokeyrules Wrote: I gave him the b- because he took a 1B when he had Kodo, when they could have used another pitcher or something who I think is better than the 1B. After all I said he was the best or second best 1B........... I just said selecting a 1B at 2nd pick is not what I would have done.

i just think you should be giving out grades based on how good the player is at the spot they took the player. for the most part the gm's here knows their needs and plans better than other gm's.

last sim brino - 1b of the orioles was a 88/94 and already jumped, and he was looking like a stud, now this sim he got an injury and is now a 80/90, so he's going to drop some peak on his b-day. sure, he still has time to get good, but i don't think he'll be as good as what he looked just 1 sim ago. thing is you never know what the next sim holds, you'd be pretty foolish to have just 1 guy at each position and be confident that they will all develop good/great and never drop or get any injuries. you need back up plans. and if all goes well, and your other guys do develop, you can use a guy for trade bait.

i just think you should keep that in mind. i hope that kodo can stay healthy and be great, but a lot can change before he peaks, and it's possible he could have a quick peak end, so i don't know, but it's good to have options. i took who i thought was best player available. there are just never guarantees in mogul when developing specs. i'd be very happy if both kodo and mcgee develop into good starting players, but i also realize that is no guarantee, no matter how good they look today.

Yeah I probably should have done it that way, I usually do, I guess I was just surprised you would take one after a good one, and that being said for Cleveland I wanted Redwine, even though they have Keil.

So I apolgoize if it looks a little harsh on that, as you know me, you know I meant nothing by it.


11-20 is now up and 21-30 will be up hopefully by tomorrow night