+- First Class Mogul (https://www.firstclassmogul.com)
+-- Forum: General Manager's Office (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=26)
+--- Forum: Trade Central (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+---- Forum: Trades Vetoed (https://www.firstclassmogul.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=36)
+---- Thread: DET-PIT (/showthread.php?tid=11315)
DET-PIT - Peter - 02-15-2012
PIT gets
P Santos Macies 92/94 26 yo min
DET gets
2B Micah Izabel 83/97 23 yo min
RP Eric Strickland 78/86 21 yo min
SP George Toth 82 23 yo min
i accept, i really love izabel and im also a big fan of strickland too but im also a big fan of macies
RE: DET-PIT - Stratford - 02-15-2012
I accept.I love having good youth on my team
RE: DET-PIT - mattynokes - 02-15-2012
(02-15-2012, 08:15 PM)Stratford Wrote: I accept.I love having good youth on my team
Then why trade Macies? I think the ratings mask Izabel as a better player than he really is. He looks all contact, nothing else to me. And for that to be the only really good thing to come out of this trade seems too little for what might be one of the game's best young SPs.
Furthermore, I don't think you gave any indication in your block that he'd be available and a player like this should probably be shopped.
I'll wait to see what the other mods say before voting.
RE: DET-PIT - Mad_Trapper - 02-15-2012
hmm I will approve it but I would have liked to see Macies Shopped around as he should have commended alot more return
RE: DET-PIT - AndyP - 02-15-2012
I thought you were trying to trade contracts.....why would you trade someone with no contract?
The justification doesn't add up here, I'd like to hear more.
RE: DET-PIT - Stratford - 02-15-2012
I wanted to get rid of him anyways. I like to have some younger talent and I'm more of an offensive guy anyways
RE: DET-PIT - AndyP - 02-15-2012
If you're more of an offensive guy...why are two of the players you got in return pitchers and not hitters?
I don't mean to push you too hard, but you're dealing a pitcher making nothing who has three years of team control and you're getting a fifth starter and a couple of decent players.
I think you'd find the market for an arm like Macies MUCH higher than this.
I'm guessing we can safely say Matty and I are both vetos.
RE: DET-PIT - hokeyrules - 02-15-2012
Veto in a heartbeat.
RE: DET-PIT - jps93 - 02-15-2012
nvm veto. this deal was done anyway